Cons:
I felt really bad about my muddled potty training with Levi. I'm sorry, dude, I had no idea I was doing it wrong. The author really lays it on thick about potty training at the right time, especially before the kid's 3rd birthday and is completely unapologetic. I guess this is a pro just disguised as a con because I felt so bad. However, I really love how adamant the author is about needing to get potty training done within a certain window and what the consequences are for your child if you don't.
Language. It's occasional, but if you're offended by that kind of thing, be forewarned.
I've read better how-to non-fiction books, even parenting books. I would have liked it if this one were a little more scientific, but I'm not sure if there's very much scientific research out there that has been done on potty training besides whatever the diaper companies do, and they're biased.
Pros:
Simple and direct instructions on how to teach your child to use the potty. I felt like the author spelled it out well enough that I could follow her method confidently.
Dedication to the parent's judgment and making sure the parent is committed to potty training once and for all.
Relates potty training to learning any other skill, and reminds us of this throughout the book.
Emphasizes that learning to use the potty correctly is a life skill and it's more important than getting a head start on other things that people are teaching toddlers these days (eg ABCs, colors, shapes, basic math, etc).
Conveys confidence in any 2-year-old's ability to master potty training. The point is made that if they're smart enough to learn to count, the ABCs, or anything else like that, then they're smart enough to learn to use the potty correctly.
Humor. Again, it can get a little on the potty humor side, but what do you expect from a book called "OH CRAP! POTTY TRAINING"?
Helps you look at potty training from the child's point of view, which helps with any problems that may come up
Encouragement to keep going even through accidents and discouragement. I feel like there is a realistic time schedule set, not the 3 days that I'd like but suspect won't happen (even though she says that's possible, but not every kid will get that). My biggest difficulty the first time through was expecting that if I did it right and at my child's pace, there would be few, if any, accidents.
Overall, as I'm sure you can tell, I liked this book. I have a lot more confidence going into my 2nd potty training having read it.
____________________________________________________
Post potty-training thoughts:
This book helped me understand a LOT more about the way a toddler thinks about potty training, diapers, and bodily functions, haha. I thought the process would take a lot longer than it actually did, because the author prepares you for the longest-case scenario. Also, I think sometimes underwear can be a positive motivator. You want to wear underwear like Mommy, Daddy, and your older sibling(s)? Okay. But you have to keep it clean and dry!
One thing that the book either didn't talk about at all or only very little was siblings and how they'd be affected by potty training. Levi was ultimately EXTREMELY helpful (I can't emphasize it enough. He was amazing), but at the beginning, he didn't know how to help and actually made it harder for Cecil to learn. Some ideas or examples of how potty training with siblings goes down would have been helpful.
My two-year-old was so excited to do his business in the potty (and all the associated stuff with that) that he would only pee or poop a little bit, flush it down, then repeat. Seriously. For at least half an hour at a time, if not more. Thankfully, when we had a discussion about where poop and pee go and gave him some underwear to put on, he is much more efficient with his potty use. Yay!
Cecil did better as soon as we had a talk about where pee and poop goes (in the potty, of course). Before that, most of his accidents were when he was wearing pants, and sometimes he'd ask for pants or a diaper when it was time for him to use the potty. The book was spot on about how pants/underwear feel more like a diaper than otherwise. His other accidents were at night in bed.
Last night was our first all dry night, and he's been wearing underwear today. We've had a couple of outings--our longest yesterday--and he's done well in the van and in public areas. I think I'm safe to say that the hardest part of potty training is over--and amazingly, it took less than a week!


