I recently (about 2 months ago) read a book--
Difficult Mothers by Terri Apter. It is, of course, about having a difficult mother. The book describes in some detail how to cope with a difficult mother, but it seemed to me that for the most part, it defined what a difficult mother is and described five different ways in which mothers can be difficult. The book was somewhat instructive, but it wasn't something that I'd go out of my way to say, "Read this! It helps!" to someone who had a difficult relationship with their mother. However, the author did put forth one idea that I thought hit the nail on the head, and I paraphrase:
"There are two kinds of mothers. Difficult mothers and good-enough mothers. Good-enough mothers make mistakes and frustrate their children, but children have more good experiences and memories with these mothers than bad ones. Children with difficult mothers have had a more negative than positive experience with their mothers."
Another thing she said also rang true:
"Sometimes a mother can be good-enough for one child but difficult for another."
_______________________________________
For me, I had more good experiences than bad with my mother. She was good-enough. Yes, there were odd things she did and restrictions out that wazoo, but I knew she loved me. I knew she appreciated me. I knew that she prayed for each of my siblings and me individually every night, which is saying something, since there are 10 of us. I knew that I was important to her.
I remember her calling me her "jewel" many times when I helped in the kitchen.
I remember her singing "When We're Helping We're Happy" when we did work around the yard when I was little. I would sing, too, and I
was happy.
I remember her playing games with me when I was little, and giving me "horsey" rides on her leg.
I remember her staying up late so she'd be awake when I got home from a social event when I was a teenager or spending the summer at home when I was in college.
I remember her encouraging me to have root beer floats in the kitchen with my friends after a group date while she went to a different part of the house and did something else.
I remember her knowing everything about birds and flowers--or at least what seemed like everything! I loved it when she'd spend time with me telling me about the different varieties of plants and animals that surrounded us.
I remember picnics in the park after kindergarten while we waited for the other kids to get out of school. The big kids were so jealous.
She helped me forge incredibly strong ties with my siblings by encouraging us to play and spend time together.
I remember going on field trips with her and the other kids that I'm sure required a lot of planning.
I remember that Mom waited on my siblings and me hand and foot when any of us were sick.
Mom taught me honesty. She taught me integrity. She taught me to love the Lord. She gave me the tools to become the person I am today, and I like the person I've become.
There are a lot of good memories. However, several of my siblings have or had a difficult relationship with our mom, and I understand why. I think the hardest thing about having her as a mother was her unpredictable mood. If she was in a good mood, then it was usually pretty easy to get along with her. If she was in a bad mood, we warned each other about it and tried to stay out of her way. She would yell at us and yell at us some more to get us to do things she wanted. It got especially bad as Dad and Mom's relationship started to deteriorate more and more. I felt so bad for the younger kids who still lived at home. Mom was frustrated because they were rebellious and disrespectful, and they were rebellious and disrespectful because they were yelled at and criticized all the time. I talked to Mom about it and told her that the kids would respond better if she used different tactics. She told me that she had
tried other tactics, but they just didn't work. The only thing that got the kids to do anything (chores, homework, adhering to Mom's moral standards) was intimidation. I tried telling her that she needed to be more consistent, but I'm sure it was incredibly difficult to change an ingrained habit that seemed to have results (at least in the short term) when she didn't have anyone she could turn to emotionally that could buoy her up when she got discouraged.
I never before realized how isolated my mother was. She didn't have a good relationship with Dad by that time. Her children avoided her. She didn't have friends from church (Mom has always been kind of shy). Her brothers and their families were all busy with their own things. She didn't have friends at work because she didn't work outside the home. No wonder she was always cranky.
Anyway. I'm rambling now, but sometimes I am afraid that I will resort to the same tactics that Mom did. Even though I logically know that other tactics work better, what if I let frustration get the best of me when Levi is misbehaving? That behavior is what was modeled for me. It would be so much easier. Lately, I've caught myself becoming really frustrated when Levi has been cranky all day and nothing I do helps. How do I stop the cycle?
It's a hypothetical question. I know how to stop the cycle. Learn all I can from parenting books about positive discipline, and apply it. Make sure I have reminders where I'll see them frequently. Recognize the built-in rewards my beautiful, trusting, and well-adjusted (or at least that is how I
hope they'll turn out!) children give me when I apply the principles well. Teach my children as Heavenly Father teaches
his children--teach them what is right, but let them make mistakes. Make sure that
my emotional, spiritual, and physical needs are met as well as theirs. Lean on my husband for support. Talk to him openly about my fears (which I have done), ask for advice, and get reassurance. Pray for help.
______________________________
There is a dual meaning in the title of this post. You can interpret "Loving Mothers" as mothers who are loving or as children loving their mothers. I think this post is about both.